They have the best pumpkin pie, me and my husband drive 55min for this.....haven't had a chance to try any other flavor yet but I highly recommend the pumpkin pie.

Pie place Was looking for a desert place. Checked the highest rated reviews. Didn't meet my minimum review count of 1000, but doesn't look like many places review Pie places. This place has been here 8 years. Nice place, with a great bakery smell. Nice decor. Tried the CHOCOLATE CREAM and Key Lime. Smooth texture. Dark chocolate taste. The key lime was smooth and creamy. Looking forward to coming back and trying the other flavors.

Stopped by and picked up 4 different pies - buttermilk, Nanny's pecan, and chewy chocolate chip, and apple. Kids who were working behind the counter looked to be newer to the place as they were unable to make any recommendations when we asked for one. Shop itself is very small, couple of barstools inside and couple of tables outside but not a place were one can go to get dessert and coffee and sit down to enjoy. The only pie we liked the most was buttermilk (despite it being dense - like a fudge on a pie shell). Although I'm not a fan of pecan pie, I liked theirs. Overall good spot to get sweet tooth cravings satisfied, none of the flavors stood out or were memorable, so I wouldn't go out of my way to return again. But for those who live in the area, it might be a good option for pies.

Saw the little pie shop after having lunch across the parking lot. Upon walking in you see the display case filled with cold pies and next to it a plethora of additional pies. A nice woman came out the back to help and she said she was the owner. They have small pies and large pies. So many choices. We got 4 small pies to go. They are best heated up with a scoop of vanilla ice cream on top. Enjoy

We had already eaten across the street but the name was too enticing to pass. Glad we stopped. There were regular sized pies but we opted for the individual ones. Three of us got apple. I'm not into cooked apples. The customer in front of me informed me that the turtle pecan pie was seasonal. Sounded good to me. So glad I chose wisely. There were raves about the apple. Mine was a cloud of sweetness. Also not a crust person but I was all in. Don't know what else to say. Get here!

Friendly service. Cute little to-go style counter service pie shop. Nice variety of regular and mini pies. They shave a rewards program where you can also get a free mini pie for your birthday.

I've been pretty into pies recently and had just finished dinner across the street when I spotted Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop. I'd seen people rave about it on Yelp and had it bookmarked for a while now. The shop is small and cute and had a myriad of pies on display. I just wanted a small bite so I got a mini 4"strawberry cream pie, which basically equates to a hearty single slice. It was tasty and not super sweet. It was a little too much cream for me in proportion to the rest of the pie but otherwise, a tasty post-dinner treat. I'll definitely need to stop in again soon to try another seasonal pie flavor for the holidays!

I was lucky enough to try samples of different pies at Food That Rocks when Buttermilk Sky Pie had a booth there earlier this year. I was informed to sign up for the birthday club and I wound receive a free mini pie and I quickly did. I received my email last month and I gladly went to go pick up the pie. There were so many pies to choose from but I decided on apple since it tasted so good the first time I tried it. Unfortunately, I had a 45 minute drive home and the pie did not make it back since I immediately ate it once I got in the car. Next time I return, I will definitely pick up more then one. Don't walk, run to try their pies!